OBGYN or Midwife: Which Option is Right for You?

It doesn’t even feel like it was that long ago that I was pregnant with my first born, Caden. I was deciding between a midwife and an OBGYN (obstetrician gynecologist), opting for a midwife since I was hoping for a birth experience that would be low-intervention and focused on holistic care. And I found a midwife program at a local hospital. I loved that prenatal visits felt more personal and supportive since they were in a group with other expecting moms. Each session, our midwife would walk us through aspects of labor and delivery, providing insights on what to expect and what choices we had.

One thing I do always want to share with expecting moms is something I hadn’t fully anticipated—the rotation system you might find with a midwife. This means the midwife who supports you through pregnancy isn’t always the one on call during labor, and that was a challenge for me when I went into labor with Caden. I ended up with a midwife I didn’t connect with as well, and after hours of pushing, I ultimately had an emergency C-section. The experience left me wondering if things might have felt and gone differently with a provider I knew better.

With my daughter Willow, I chose an OB for prenatal care, since I was anticipating the possibility of another C-section. And I did know I wanted to try a different hospital. I was so happy to find that my OB experience felt just as personalized as my time with a midwife, if not more so. 

Which brings me to this: I believe so much of the birth experience comes down to the individual provider and their bedside manner. So, if you’re deciding between a midwife and an OB, the first things I’d highly recommend are asking other moms for recommendations in your area, as well as considering what kind of care feels right for you and your birth plan.

OBGYN vs. midwife

What's the difference between an OBGYN and a midwife?

Choosing between an OBGYN and a midwife is a big decision on your birth journey. Both options bring something unique to the table. And finding the care team that best aligns with your preferences and goals should be the priority. Are you drawn to the medical expertise and structured approach of an OBGYN, or does the holistic, hands-on support of a midwife speak to you more? Understanding the strengths of each role can help you shape a birth experience that feels just right for you and your growing family.

OBGYN

An OBGYN is a medical doctor specializing in women's reproductive health, pregnancy, and childbirth. Their training includes medical school, residency, and often additional fellowship work. OBGYNs are equipped to manage both routine and high risk pregnancies. This extensive background allows them to offer a structured, medically-focused approach to prenatal care and delivery, which can provide reassurance for those preferring a more clinical and predictable path during pregnancy.

OBGYNs can diagnose and treat conditions related to the female reproductive system. They're also skilled in procedures like C-sections when needed. If you prefer having a wide range of medical tools and technologies available, an OBGYN might be the right choice for you. With access to advanced tools like ultrasounds and fetal monitoring, they can track your progress and address issues early.

Choosing an OBGYN may be the right fit if you value regular, structured visits and thorough monitoring of both you and your baby’s health. Working within a hospital setting or clinic environment, OBGYNs also often collaborate with other specialists, such as anesthesiologists or neonatologists, making sure you receive comprehensive care should any complications arise. If having immediate access to specialized care and the option for more intensive medical support aligns with your vision of a safe and supportive birth experience, then an OBGYN may be the best choice for you.

Midwife

A midwife is a dedicated healthcare professional specializing in pregnancy, childbirth, and postpartum care, offering a nurturing and empowering experience for expectant parents. Through specific education and training, midwives focus on creating a healthy, supportive environment for both the physical and emotional aspects of pregnancy.

There are various types of midwives with different training and practices. Certified Nurse Midwives (CNMs) are registered nurses with advanced training, practicing in all 50 states, mainly in hospitals or clinics. Certified Professional Midwives (CPMs) focus on home or birthing center births, following the Midwives Model of Care for low-intervention settings. Direct-Entry Midwives (DEMs) gain expertise through programs or apprenticeships, usually working outside hospitals.

Midwives provide a more personalized approach to care, often focusing on the natural process of childbirth and encouraging parents to feel confident and empowered. They offer comprehensive prenatal care, assisting with regular checkups, health screenings, and wellness guidance tailored to each family’s needs. When it’s time for labor and delivery, a midwife is there to guide and support, often working alongside you on birthing plans and comfort techniques, providing continuous care throughout the process.

Their role extends into the postpartum period, where they remain a source of guidance and support. Midwives are available to help with breastfeeding, newborn care, and overall recovery, prioritizing both the physical and emotional well-being of new parents. If you’re looking for a holistic and individualized approach that focuses on promoting a healthy pregnancy and birth experience, a midwife may be the ideal choice.

OBGYN’s role in pregnancy

For moms-to-be who want a structured, medical approach with comprehensive support, OBGYNs bring a wealth of expertise in both routine and high risk pregnancies. Here’s how an OBGYN supports you through each phase:

1. Comprehensive prenatal care: OBGYNs handle everything from regular checkups to advanced testing, using diagnostic tools like ultrasounds and fetal monitoring to keep track of you and your baby’s health. They also provide guidance on nutrition, lifestyle, and prenatal vitamins to help you feel your best.
2. Medical expertise in high risk pregnancies: With years of specialized training, OBGYNs are equipped to monitor and manage high risk situations, including gestational diabetes, preeclampsia, and more, ensuring close monitoring to safeguard you and your baby.
3. Range of intervention options: Whether it’s coordinating epidurals, performing cesarean sections, or handling emergency situations, OBGYNs provide access to the full spectrum of medical interventions, giving you peace of mind with immediate access to procedures if needed.
4. Collaborative hospital support: OBGYNs typically work within hospital or clinic settings, allowing for easy collaboration with anesthesiologists, neonatologists, and other specialists, so you have a well-rounded team ready if additional support is necessary.
5. Postpartum medical care: After delivery, OBGYNs offer medical follow-up, monitoring recovery, managing any complications, and supporting physical and emotional health. From postpartum checkups to ongoing women’s health services, they continue to be a resource as you transition into motherhood.

 

 

Midwife’s role in pregnancy

As mentioned above, choosing a midwife can bring a more personal, hands-on approach during your pregnancy. Here’s what midwives offer expectant moms:

1. Personalized and communal prenatal care: Midwives often spend more time during prenatal visits and focus on having a comfortable space to discuss health goals and questions. Some practices even offer group sessions, creating a supportive community for expecting moms.
2. Natural birth expertise: Midwives are skilled in supporting natural, low-intervention births, guiding you through techniques like breathing exercises, varied labor positions, and other comfort methods for a calm, empowering experience.
3. Holistic health guidance: Midwives often integrate emotional well-being, lifestyle advice, and natural wellness practices to provide a well-rounded approach to prenatal health.
4. Labor and delivery support: During labor, midwives offer hands-on support, pain management techniques, and encouragement. For moms seeking a natural birth setting, they help create a warm, low-stress environment.
5. Postpartum follow-up: After delivery, midwives can continue to support you, including home visits for newborn care, breastfeeding help, and recovery guidance, so that you're cared for as you transition into parenthood.

 

 

Deciding whether an OBGYN or midwife is right for you

Choosing between an OBGYN and a midwife is a personal choice that comes down to what feels right for you and your vision of support. Here’s what to consider as you make this decision:

1. Level of intervention: If you'd prefer a more traditional medical setting with access to all forms of medical intervention, an OBGYN might be your ideal choice. They are equipped to manage high risk pregnancies and perform surgeries like C-sections if needed.
2. Personalized care: Midwives often provide a personalized, more holistic approach to care with more time spent in each visit. They emphasize natural, low-intervention births, which could be appealing if you’re seeking a hands-on, engaging approach.
3. Support system: Consider the type of support you want during your pregnancy. Midwives are known for creating a supportive, community-focused environment, which can be comforting during this time.
4. Insurance and costs: Carefully review your health care coverage, as costs can vary. While OBGYN services are generally covered by insurance, midwives might require some out-of-pocket expenses unless associated with a hospital.
5. Birth setting: Your preferred birth setting can influence your decision. Midwives often work in birthing centers or at home, while OBGYNs are typically based in hospitals. Deciding where you feel more comfortable can guide your decision.

Ultimately, the best choice is the one that aligns with your birth preferences, medical needs, and personal comfort.

Why is there a rising trend towards choosing midwives?

There's been a real shift happening toward midwives. Wondering why? Midwives bring a more personalized, patient-centered approach that many expecting families find deeply comforting. With a focus on holistic and natural childbirth, midwives often spend longer in each appointment, making time for in-depth discussions, and offering space for questions and support that feels personal.

As birthing centers and home births grow in popularity, the demand for midwives has followed. This definitely reflects a desire for birth experiences that are as flexible and individualized as they are supportive. This trend toward midwifery care highlights the importance of meaningful emotional and physical support, tailored to each family's unique preferences.

What are the considerations for high risk pregnancies?

For high risk pregnancies, an OBGYN’s specialized expertise is often essential because of the potential complications that can arise. OBGYNs are trained to closely monitor and manage high risk conditions, keeping both mom and baby’s safety front and center.

That said, midwives can still play a valuable role, offering emotional support, guidance, and education as part of a collaborative care team. In many cases, a combined approach between an OBGYN and a midwife gives you the best of both worlds, blending medical care with personalized support. The right provider for you will ultimately depend on your needs and the specific nature of your pregnancy.

Deciding between an OBGYN and midwife: what’s the best fit for you?

The big picture here? Choosing between an OBGYN and a midwife comes down to your preferences, health needs, and the type of birth experience you envision.

OBGYNs bring in-depth medical training and are especially suited for high risk pregnancies or those requiring potential interventions, like C-sections. Midwives, on the other hand, offer a more holistic, low-intervention approach, ideal for low-risk pregnancies and those who prefer a calm, empowering environment.

Here are a few things to keep in mind:

1. Medical needs: For high risk pregnancies or if you have pre-existing medical conditions, an OBGYN can offer a more structured approach and quick access to interventions.
2. Birthing environment: If a more serene, personalized birthing experience speaks to you, midwives excel at creating this, especially for home or birth center settings.
3. Support team: OBGYNs often work within larger hospital teams, including anesthesiologists and nurses, while midwives usually provide a more one-on-one, hands-on experience.
4. Doulas for additional support: If you want added emotional and physical support, consider layering your care with a doula. Doulas can work alongside both OBGYNs and midwives to provide continuity of care and additional guidance.

Finding the best fit means balancing your health needs with the level of personal support you’d like. Explore your options, talk to providers, and trust your instincts to shape the birth experience that feels right for you and your growing family.

 

 

And if you're looking for more guidance during your pregnancy and postpartum, check out insights on birth plans and the benefits of a night nurse. For even more thoughts and tips on motherhood, pregnancy, and what else lies ahead, be sure to subscribe to the newsletter!

Author